What I have noticed for this dub in particular, is that it drives people into two different categories: those that love the original and hate the dub, or those that love the original and like the dub.
Yuri On Ice!! (Dub) First Impressions
I have way too much praise to give to the dub of this show
Nanbaka (Dub) First Impressions
It had me laughing more than the original Japanese version.